Housing

One of the most critical access issues for grandparents and other relatives and the children they raise is the lack of affordable housing. Although housing is an issue for many Americans, grandparent and other relative caregivers face certain unique barriers.


INTRODUCTION

One of the most critical access issues for grandparents and other relatives and the children they raise is the lack of affordable housing.

Unique Barriers
Although housing is an issue for many Americans, grandparent and other relative caregivers face certain unique barriers:

  1. They frequently take on caregiving responsibilities with absolutely no warning, let alone with 9 months to plan.
  2. Many of these caregivers live on fixed incomes and/or in small apartments and houses that are not suitable for children.
  3. They may no longer be able to afford their apartments or houses after assuming the extra expenses of raising children.
  4. Many caregivers are physically unable to walk stairs with children and strollers.
  5. If they live in senior housing where children are often not allowed, they may be subject to eviction if the children are discovered.
  6. The presence of additional children may violate their private lease agreements.
  7. If they do not have legal custody of the children, they are frequently unable to convince the housing authorities to recognize their need for larger apartments.

Lack of Legal Custody
Throughout the country, this last category of barriers -- the lack of legal custody -- is a serious issue for many grandfamilies.  Some housing authorities are unlawfully requiring relatives to have legal custody or guardianship of the children in order to qualify as ‘families’ for assisted housing. Many relatives lack legal relationships with the children due to a variety of factors, including the costs of legal proceedings and potential disruption of family dynamics.
 

Housing authorities require legal custody or guardianship to attempt to prevent fraud, like an applicant who misrepresents that he or she is raising children in order to request additional bedrooms. These fraud concerns can be legitimate, but addressing them by requiring legal relationships is not.
 

Although HUD has not issued specific policy on this issue, federal law is clear. The Fair Housing Act defines ‘familial status’ to include grandparents and other relatives without legal custody of the children in the second part of its definition:

 

"Familial status" means one or more individuals (who have attained the age of 18 years) being domiciled with

(1) a parent or another person having legal custody of such individual or individuals; or 

(2) the designee of such parent or other personhaving custody, with the written permission of such parent of other person. [1] 

 

HUD includes in its Occupancy Handbook ways to verify family composition that address fraud concerns without requiring legal custody or guardianship:  

 

A. Owners may seek verification of family composition only if the owner has a clear, written policy. Verification is not required.

B. Owners may use a policy to verify family composition to determine whether children reside in the household 50 percent or more of the time, as well as to determine the appropriate unit size for the family …

C. If an owner determines it necessary to verify family composition, information may be collected from sources listed in Appendix 3.[2] 

 

According to that Appendix, acceptable sources of verification are birth certificates; divorce actions; drivers’ licenses; employer records; income tax returns; marriage certificates; school records; social security administration records; social service agency records; support payment records; utility bills; and Veteran Administration records. Basically, documents that show the child is living with the relative.

Once jurisdictions are made aware of HUD policy on this issue, they have often stopped requiring legal custody or guardianship. 
 

GOVERNMENT ASSISTED HOUSING OPTIONS FOR GRANDFAMILIES

Currently many grandparent and other relative-headed families qualify for several types of government assisted housing. However, these families face a severe shortage of safe, affordable housing as do most other low income populations.[3] The lack of reasonably priced, large, two or more bedroom units is an increasing problem as the public housing system increasingly relies on the Section 8 voucher program for the provision of housing to low income people. [4] Furthermore, even when assisted housing is available, often it is not designed with relative-headed families in mind, does not include special features for both older people and children, and rarely has supportive services to help with the multiple barriers these families often encounter.
 

HOUSING DEVELOPMENTS SPECIFICALLY FOR GRANDFAMILIES

In response to the limited housing options for grandparents and other relatives raising children, a few nonprofit developers and public housing authorities have relied on various public and/or private financing sources to specifically design housing developments for the families. In 1998, the first housing program for grandparents raising grandchildren, known as GrandFamilies House, opened in Dorchester, Massachusetts. Many lessons were learned from this pioneer and seven years later, in 2005, the first new ground-up construction for grandparents raising grandchildren started serving families in the South Bronx, New York.

That development – known as GrandParent Family Apartments – has 50 apartments (40 two-bedroom and 10 three-bedroom) in a six-story, 66,470 square-foot building. The apartments and building are designed to respond to the needs of older caregivers, youth, and children. Design elements include wide hallways, emergency buzzers in each unit, handrails in the bathrooms and hallways, laundry facilities on each floor, and extensive community space with separate rooms for caregivers, youth, and young children. In that space, comprehensive on-site services are available, including educational before- and after-school activities, support groups, and case management. The development also features 24 hour security, including multiple staff at the front desk verifying identities and cross referencing visitors with court orders.

Since GrandParent Family Apartments opened, several other developments around the country have started serving the families, and other groups are contemplating building their own grandfamily housing with services on-site.  For more information, see Generations United's 2019 State of Grandfamilies Report on affordable housing.
 

TWO FEDERAL HOUSING LAWS FOR GRANDFAMILIES

 

HOME Rent Waivers

As part of the American Homeownership and Economic Opportunity Act of 2000, 42 U.S.C. section 12745(a)(6)(A) and (B) was passed. This provision allows a project owner to apply for a waiver so that rents can rise to fair market value for (1) a dwelling unit supported by section 8 subsidies that houses at least one elderly person who is the head of the household and is raising grandchildren, great grandchildren, great nieces, and/or great nephews (2) within a housing program that also receives HOME funds.
 
HOME is a federal block grant program that provides resources to states, localities, and non-profit housing sponsors to meet low income housing needs. The problem prior to passage of this law was that although tenant-based Section 8 vouchers allow rents to be fair market value, rents were restricted to often-lower HOME levels if the property also received those federal funds.
 
This decrease in revenue was a serious challenge to GrandFamilies House. It was experiencing an annual operating deficit of approximately $38,000, which was jeopardizing its long-term sustainability. The feasibility of developing additional housing programs for grandparents and other relatives raising children was also a challenge. The waiver allowed GrandFamilies House to obtain fair market value for its rents, which at the time the law was enacted, meant roughly $54,000 a year in revenue. This increased revenue allowed for the continued viability of GrandFamilies House, and facilitates the development of additional grandfamilies housing.
 

Living Equitably: Grandparents Aiding Children and Youth Act of 2003

LEGACY, Living Equitably: Grandparents Aiding Children and Youth Act of 2003, Public Law 108-186, was enacted in December 2003 as part of the American Dream Downpayment Act. When LEGACY became law, it authorized $10 million to accomplish its objectives, but because it lacked a specific appropriation, HUD failed to take significant steps to implement it. Almost two years later, in November 2005, $4 million was specifically earmarked for its implementation. Generations United successfully worked with Members of Congress, including Senator Mary Landrieu (D-LA) and Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) to obtain funding so that HUD could implement LEGACY.
 

LEGACY contains three provisions:

 

(1) Develop and distribute grants for not less than two and not more than four demonstration projects to create housing for grandparents and other relatives raising children.

(2) Provide training to HUD personnel on issues facing relatives raising children.

(3) Work with the U.S. Bureau of the Census to conduct a national study of the housing needs of grandparents and other relatives raising children and make recommendations to Congress based on that study. 

 

Demonstration Projects
In December 2008, two demonstration grants were awarded to expand “intergenerational” housing for grandparents or other relatives aged 62 or more who are raising child(ren). The age limitation exists because these grant funds are available under the federal elderly housing program, known as section 202. HUD awarded a total of $3,906,964 to a demonstration project in urban Chicago and another in rural Tennessee.

The Chicago development opened during the fall of 2011 and has 10 units consisting of three and four bedrooms that can serve up to 34 residents. The Smithville, TN development opened in the spring of 2011 and has nine two-bedroom units plus a manager’s unit for up to 20 residents. Both projects provide a range of supportive services on site that are tailored to meet the needs of seniors, children, and the families as a whole. In Chicago, residents have access to after-school and summer programs for children; General Educational Development (GED) and English as a Second Language (ESL) courses; a financial education program; health classes and screenings; heath care services for seniors; and job education. In Smithville, the Upper Cumberland Development District’s Relative Caregiver Program is available. This program provides easy to follow information about the existing resources available to families and fills in gaps where services are not available. 

Training
On May 30, 2007, HUD -- with its subcontractor Generations United – developed and broadcast a three hour satellite and Internet training to HUD’s regional and headquarters’ staff. That comprehensive training covered LEGACY, in addition to an overview of the affordable housing issues faced by grandparents and other relatives raising children, how other housing programs and supportive services can help these families, and housing developments specifically designed for them.

National Study
After the training, HUD released its Intergenerational Housing Needs and HUD Program Options Report to Congress, which fulfilled the last requirement of the LEGACY law.


CONCLUSION

In the last fifteen years, federal laws and developments around the country have begun a trend to respond to the unique housing needs of grandfamilies. Much remains to be done, but policymakers and programmers are well on their way.

If you have any comments concerning this analysis, please contact its author: Ana Beltran, Co-Director, Generations United's National Center on Grandfamilies, at abeltran@gu.org.

 


[1] 42 U.S.C. section 3602(k).
[2] HUD. (2013). Handbook 4350.3 Rev-1: Occupancy Requirements of Subsidized Multifamily Housing Programs.  Washington, D.C.: HUD. https://www.hud.gov/sites/documents/43503HSGH.PDF

[3] Kaufman, S. and Goldberg-Glen, R. (2000). A comparison of low income caregivers in public housing: Differences in grandparents and non grandparent needs and problems. In B. Hayslip and R. Goldberg-Glen (Eds.) Grandparents raising grandchildren: Theoretical, empirical and clinical perspectives. NY: Springer Publishing Co. pp. 369-382. 

[4] Sand P. (2001). Generations united under one roof: A briefing paper on housing barriers for grandparents raising grandchildren. Unpublished paper.


Dorothy was initially unprepared to raise her grandchildren. Her daughter died suddenly ten years ago of a brain aneurysm, after a battle with drug abuse. Dorothy took custody of her 3 year old granddaughter, and 10 and 18 year old grandsons. She had helped raise four other grandchildren, but her daughter’s death left her in a difficult financial situation and with full-time responsibility for the children. Despite working for the same company for thirty years and her big retirement dreams, Dorothy agreed to serve as “mother” for the second time.

Caring for children full-time meant significant changes for Dorothy. She had to stop working to provide around-the-clock care for the children. Yet, she still needed to find a way to provide for their needs and adequate housing for her family of four. On top of that, she needed to find a way to fund her oldest grandson’s college education. To make all of this possible, she knew she needed change in her housing situation. Fortunately, she learned of a new building project by Presbyterian Senior Services. The new facility was the first group of apartments in the country built from the ground up specifically for grandparents raising grandchildren. For Dorothy the move meant “a change of life” for her grandchildren. To her delight, everything from tutoring to day care is available to the family under one roof.

Of the building project by Presbyterian Senior Services, Dorothy says, “I just cannot tell you how the apartments are, I love them to death.” Housing assistance meant that Dorothy could focus her energy on her grandchildren’s emotional and educational needs. Dorothy’s unending commitment to her children and grandchildren’s education has brought its rewards. Today, she is the proud mother of an English professor, a psychiatrist, and the proud grandmother of a grandson with a PhD in English.

Dorothy is fortunate to live in South Bronx, New York which is home to one of few housing programs created to provide help to grandparents and other relatives raising grandchildren. These grandparents face special challenges. Children often come into their care unexpectedly and homes may be too small to accommodate the larger family. Others may live in senior housing where children are not allowed. Nearly 20% of grandparents raising grandchildren who rent their homes spend more than half of their income on rent. Federal and state policies that support special housing for grandparents or other relatives raising grandchildren can help provide stability for families like Dorothy’s.


State of Grandfamilies in America 2019 A Place to Call Home: Building Affordable Housing for Grandfamilies

Generations United's signature report in 2019 focuses on affordable housing. Although affordable housing is a challenging issue for many Americans, grandfamilies are in a unique situation. The caregivers are often responding to an urgent situation with little to no planning time to find suitable housing and no legal relationship to the children. Join Generations United in taking action on concrete recommendations to replicate housing innovations for grandfamilies.

 

2012 Advocates' Guide to Housing & Community Development Policy

Contains a chapter on LEGACY, the nation's first affordable housing law for grandparents and other relatives raising children. The chapter also covers other housing issues faced by grandfamilies. See pages 114-117. (2012).
 

Grandparents and Other Relatives Raising Children: An Action Agenda to Create Affordable Housing Opportunities
Provides an overview of housing issues faced by grandfamilies, existing federal laws that can help, housing specifically for grandfamilies, and recommended action areas and projects for creating additional affordable housing opportunities developed during Generations United's first national expert housing symposium specifically for grandfamilies (2005). 
 

Intergenerational Housing Needs and HUD Program Options Report to Congress 
This report was mandated by LEGACY, the nation's first affordable housing law specifically for grandparents and other relatives raising children.